Real Cases: How Hong Kong Courts Sentenced Assault and Wounding
Published: 2026-07-08
Hong Kong's violence charges form a ladder, and in these six decided cases the higher the rung the heavier the sentence: common assault with a knife used to threaten drew 2 months; assault occasioning actual bodily harm (AOABH) drew 3 months 2 weeks in one case and 4 months 2 weeks in total, together with five common assaults, in another; s. 19 wounding drew 28 months; and s. 17 wounding with intent drew 2 years 6 months and 5 years 4 months in two cases, both after pleas. Neither AOABH nor s. 17 has a formal tariff, so courts worked along a gravity spectrum, with weapons, blows to the head, premeditation and group attacks, and a vulnerable victim all pushing sentences up. In the cases with a domestic setting, the defendant was still imprisoned.
About these case summaries: the summaries below were prepared by this site based on our own reading and understanding of the judgments. They are not legal advice, have no legal effect, and must not be cited as authority. Cases are identified by neutral citation only, without party names; read the originals via the HKLII links. Sentences turn on the totality of each case's circumstances; every figure below is what the cited case actually decided, never a prediction for any other case. Our full verification process for case content — full-text reading of every judgment, corrigendum checks and independent human review — is set out in our methodology .
A hypothetical scenario
Imagine an argument that turns into shoving; someone falls and is hurt, and by the time the police leave, someone is under arrest. The family's questions: what will the charge be, and how far apart are "common assault" and "wounding"? Hong Kong's violence offences form a ladder — common assault, assault occasioning actual bodily harm (AOABH, "section 39"), wounding ("section 19"), and wounding with intent ("section 17") — with dramatically different sentencing ranges. Six real judgments show how each rung was sentenced in the decided cases.
The charge ladder: six cases across four levels
Common assault — in [2021] HKCFI 2291 (CFI magistracy appeal, 2021), a footbridge confrontation: the defendant poured beer over the victim and thrust a fruit knife towards him. The magistrate found the injury's causation unproved — so acquitted on AOABH but convicted of common assault (threat of unlawful violence) — and imposed 2 months; the judgment compares an earlier case where 6 months for common assault with scissors was upheld. Both appeals dismissed ( judgment ).
AOABH ("39") — in [2024] HKCFI 1888 (CFI magistracy appeal, 2024), against a background of marital breakdown, the defendant pinned his wife of 30 years to the floor, tore out hair and knocked her head against the floor seven or eight times (occipital haematoma). A first offender; the magistrate started at 4 months, arriving at 3 months 2 weeks. The judgment states expressly there is no sentencing guideline for AOABH — each case turns on its gravity — and that attacks to the head aggravate. Appeal dismissed ( judgment ).
Employer–helper abuse ("39") — in [2024] HKCFI 526 (CFI magistracy appeal, 2024), an employer committed five common assaults and one AOABH against her foreign domestic helper over about ten months (the last injuring the helper's left eye). Total: 4 months 2 weeks; the judgment stresses deterrence to protect FDHs, describes community service as no soft option, and observes 6 months would not have been excessive. Appeal dismissed ( judgment ).
Wounding (s. 19) — in [2024] HKCA 169 (Court of Appeal, 2024), after a row outside a convenience store, the defendant returned 15 minutes later with two men, each carrying a two-foot metal bar, and beat the victim about the head (maxillary fracture, scalp laceration). The judge observed the facts "could well be charged as the aggravated offence of wounding with intent", took a 2-year-8-month starting point, and allowed only a 25% plea discount because the defendant had absconded: 28 months. Leave to appeal refused ( judgment ).
Wounding with intent (s. 17) — the heavy end — in [2013] HKCA 169 (Court of Appeal, 2013), a husband attacked his wife, ultimately with a two-foot bread knife to the neck, inflicting about twenty wounds (13 days in hospital). The trial judge started at 12 years; the Court of Appeal, recording counsel's submission that 12 years sat "at the very top of the 3–12 years range in which most wounding cases fall", substituted an 8-year starting point → 5 years 4 months after plea ( judgment ).
Wounding with intent — the mitigated end — in [2021] HKCFI 2395 (CFI first-instance sentence, 2021), a young first offender in a domestic quarrel struck at the back of the victim's head with a small chopper (~10cm blade), stopping when his mother seized it — having himself been threatened with the same chopper earlier. The judge stated "there is no tariff for this type of offence", took 3 years 9 months as the starting point, and imposed 2 years 6 months after plea ( judgment ).
The six cases at a glance
| Case | Court / year | Rung | Actual sentence |
|---|---|---|---|
| [2021] HKCFI 2291 | CFI (appeal), 2021 | Common assault (knife used to threaten) | 2 months |
| [2024] HKCFI 1888 | CFI (appeal), 2024 | AOABH (domestic; head-targeted) | 3 months 2 weeks |
| [2024] HKCFI 526 | CFI (appeal), 2024 | 5× common assault + 1× AOABH (helper abuse) | 4 months 2 weeks total |
| [2024] HKCA 169 | Court of Appeal, 2024 | s. 19 wounding (armed group revenge) | 28 months |
| [2021] HKCFI 2395 | CFI, 2021 | s. 17 wounding with intent (mitigated end) | 2 years 6 months (after plea) |
| [2013] HKCA 169 | Court of Appeal, 2013 | s. 17 (heavy end; 3–12-year range noted) | 5 years 4 months (after plea) |
What moved sentences in these cases
- Weapons: the gap between bare hands and a knife or metal bar was decisive; in the common assault case, brandishing a knife was enough for immediate custody for the conduct involved.
- Target: [2024] HKCFI 1888 states head-targeted violence aggravates.
- Premeditation and numbers: leaving and returning with armed backup ([2024] HKCA 169) pushed the case toward the higher charge.
- Victim vulnerability: the helper-abuse case emphasises deterrence where an employer abuses their position.
- No tariff ≠ no structure: neither AOABH nor s. 17 has a formal guideline, but these judgments show courts working along a gravity spectrum — s. 17 running from about 2½ years (mitigated) to sentences measured in many years.
If you or a family member is arrested
- Rights on arrest: rights if arrested ; bail: bail guide .
- The Duty Lawyer Scheme covers Magistrates'-level cases; s. 17 is generally tried higher — see legal aid .
- Charge selection (common assault vs "39" vs wounding) rests with the prosecution on the medical evidence and can shift as evidence develops — one reason to engage a criminal solicitor early.
Frequently Asked Questions
It was self-defence — am I in the clear?
The injuries were minor — will it just be common assault?
Do domestic cases get lighter sentences?
Next Steps
- Rights on arrest: Your Rights if Arrested in Hong Kong
- How bail works: How Bail Works in Hong Kong
- Duty lawyer and legal aid: Legal Aid in Hong Kong: Who Qualifies and What It Covers
- All articles in the real-case series: 案例點睇: Real Hong Kong Cases, Explained in Plain Language
- Original judgments: HKLII links above.
